The IRS Hasn't Forgotten About Your Unfiled Returns. It Just Got Around to Them.

If you received an IRS letter in 2024 about an unfiled return and then heard nothing, you may have concluded the matter went away. It didn't.
In early 2024, the IRS launched a campaign aimed at high-income nonfilers, beginning with compliance letters in more than 125,000 cases where returns hadn't been filed since 2017. A Treasury Inspector General report released in September found that many of those cases stalled: as of June 30, 2025, nearly 39,000 high-priority cases, involving more than 33,000 taxpayers, were still sitting at the first-notice stage. That pause is over. The IRS agreed with the report's recommendations and says it advanced the affected cases in March 2026. For many of these taxpayers, the next step is a return the IRS prepares itself.
What happens when the IRS files for you
When a taxpayer doesn't file, the IRS can prepare a "substitute for return" (SFR) using the W-2s and 1099s that employers, banks, brokerages, and clients sent it. That return is built to overstate what you owe:
- Filing status: single, or married filing separately, even if you're married with children.
- Deductions: the standard deduction only, with no dependents and no child tax credit.
- Business income: every dollar of 1099 income is treated as profit, with no business expenses, and then self-employment tax is added.
- Investment sales: where the IRS doesn't have your cost basis, sale proceeds can be taxed as if they were pure gain.
Late-filing and late-payment penalties and interest are then calculated on that inflated figure. In our experience, the result is often several times what the taxpayer actually owes. The bill is so large that people assume they can never pay it, so they do nothing. That is the most expensive response available.
Three deadlines that don't wait
- The 90-day letter. The IRS's Notice CP3219N gives you 90 days to challenge the proposed tax in the U.S. Tax Court. Mailing in your own return during that window does not stop the clock. If the 90 days pass, the IRS assesses its number and your options narrow considerably.
- Refunds expire. Many nonfilers are actually owed money. A refund must generally be claimed within three years of the original due date. If you never filed your 2023 return and had tax withheld, the deadline to claim any refund is April 15, 2027. The 2022 refund window has already closed.
- The statute never starts. An IRS-prepared return does not start the three-year clock the IRS has to assess additional tax. Until you file your own return, that year stays open indefinitely.
The good news
An SFR is almost always fixable. Filing an accurate replacement return can restore your correct filing status, dependents, deductions, and business expenses. Married couples can generally still elect to file jointly even after the IRS has prepared separate returns for them. The right move depends on where each year sits in the IRS process, and multi-year nonfilers usually have years at several different stages.
There are also situations where filing quickly without a plan is a mistake. One is when the correct return reports more income than the IRS knows about. Another is when bankruptcy is a possibility, because returns filed after the IRS assesses may not be dischargeable in Maryland's federal circuit. Those cases need careful sequencing before anything is signed.
Learn more: Coming Out of the Dark, Episode 7
I'll walk through the entire process in the next episode of Coming Out of the Dark: "When the IRS Files for You: Substitutes for Return, the ASFR Pipeline, and the Replacement Strategy." The episode is presented through our partnership with ALFI and covers:
- the IRS notice sequence, from the first letter through the 90-day notice;
- how to replace an IRS-prepared return;
- penalty and refund rules;
- the cases where the obvious fix creates new problems.
December 2nd at 1 PM Eastern. Register here. CPE credit is available for tax professionals.
If you have unfiled years or IRS letters you haven't opened, call us before the next deadline passes: (202) 455-6010 / info@strategictaxplanning.net.

